SPECULATION End of Skywalker saga

I know we fans are taking this to much serious, those are just a films.

But those are outrageous insults to fictional character of Luke Skywalker as we fans have known him. This is the man that brough down 2 most powerfull Sith ever, by his decision and bravery to face them. More so, by his strong unshaken belief in victory of the Light over Darkness.He came victorious from ep .VI. and saw himself that he can win, that good defeats evil if one is persistant and brave. And look in what he turns out to be in ep VIII (looking superficialy )?

However you turn it, you and people of your opinion must acknowledge, just as auhtors of the Film, that what has been done(undone) to Luke Skywalker is unbarable especially because it was unnecessary . I do not know proportion but I know many people who literally vomited on what was done to Luke, (those who were accepting those superficial interpretations as truth and that there is nothing else in this Luke's story arc.)

That is why I still have hope, until the last day,that this is not how it looks on the surface, there is something else beneath it, coming in ep IX, something like I described in previous posts.

 

Do not get me wrong please. I am not blaming you, anyone personally.Maybe Rian Johnson simply thought its cool.I know that people who in my eyes are insulting Luke Skywalker do not do this because they hate Luke Skywalker, they just do not see importance of connection and coherence, and want story to develop further between Rey and Kylo and who cares about Luke.For them (you) story justiffies any sacrifice, including Luke. That is reasonable, like when I was buying commics as a kid, and only wanted new episode, who care about old.

For me personaly however,and many others,it does not fit, that is why there is term backlash.
If Rey is not Luke's daughter(because this makes Luke's life fulfilled ) portraying Luke as it was made in ep VIII was bad and unnecessary approach with consequences that are still not fully predictable.

I am not dirrector, but if I would decide for Luke to go in my film, man he will go in creshendo anlike ever seen in cinematography. Even If I would hate Luke as a character, I would still want money to, this way I would do it to give Star Wars fans last Luke's fight, epic, in flesh. I would make him powerfull, crushing AT-AT's and pulling TIE fighters from the sky while clearing ranks of the First Order after last stregth leaves him, and than heroic death, taking Snoke with him of course.

That would be death that makes legends, and money, and better position to move on..
And episode IX could be absolutely the same .
So Lukes arc especially way he died was totally unncesseary and compromising, unless Rey is Skywalker, of course, in this case it all suddenly fitts together and turns in one of the greatest twist in cinematographic histoy that will be celebrated forever.

 

Luke has been by some interpretations trained for almost 2 years by Yoda, not in continuity of course.

Some canon experts claim that subspace travel of Millenium Falcon from Hoth to Bespin lasted few months, so this are let say 2-3 months of initial training for Luke on Dagobah, before he faced Vader on Bespin, and he was not very trained then though.

Between episode V. and VI. there is gap of at least one year , some think more in which Luke received further training from Yoda.

 

of course

You like Luke and don't sacrifice Luke, but would make Luke even weaker, jet , still strong enough to be able to lift lightsaber to kill parents of Rey.(who were of course , nobody)

You mean like new centuries old character Snoke who died for other new characters to develop themselves?. Gosh this concept requers ritual sacrifice of not just old characters, but actually inventing more old(but new) character , becase of need to have enough sacrifices for new characters to develop further.

Disney would be happy with me now, I am wise enough to make product for the main custommers profile that I expect to actually buy my product.that mean avoiding things they don't like., and its not so hard.

Example: you make film..please tell me what on Earth could make someone believe that custommers would like to see beloved Jedi Master Luke Skywalker milks docile sea creatures to obtain their milk that is , by the face of Luke when he sips it, a fermented and little shaky,still visible on his beard?
Or, Priness Leia( which in Bloodline novel we released few months ago) never uses the Force and barely senses its presence, to suddenly survive vacuum of Space and than...we all know this incident of the scene.
I mean why on Earth they think that every shock is good shock?. The same is with Rey nobody., is it so difficult, when she must not be powerful Skywalker at all(which will be logical), than at least to show to the all the progressive people of the world that by persistance and training one can acheive everything.? But no, Rey gets instant powers on a level of chosen one Anakin Skywalker and kicks ass of everything around, including poor old Luke Skywalker.
Or, why on Earth to make most perspective character in the film, Ben Solo, to kill his own father, but wait, killing was "ok" but it was not because he was decieved by Snoke instead, after he kills old crapy Snoke it turns out the reason he killed his father Han was this: why not. And custommer actually love Han, we actually make more films about Han.But we also want custommers to love Ben, who killed Han because of why not.

 

Yes I desperately want it.That is obvious.
But not because of my preference but because I want thing to be logic and plausible to be able to enjoy in films.