1. IMPORTANT! To be able to create new threads and rate posts, you need to have at least 30 posts in The Cantina.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Before posting a new thread, check the list with similar threads that will appear when you start typing the thread's title.
    Dismiss Notice

Heroes Often Dont Believe They Are Heroes Marvels Rogue One #4

Discussion in 'Star Wars: Books & Comics + Legends' started by SWNN Probe, Jul 7, 2017.

  1. SWNN Probe

    SWNN Probe Seeker

    Joined:
    Aug 29, 2016
    Posts:
    911
    Likes Received:
    1,908
    Trophy Points:
    3,842
    Credits:
    2,121
    Ratings:
    +2,768 / 6 / -6
    [​IMG]

    I love this comic adaptation of Rogue One, especially this issue. If you loved Rogue One, I urge you to start taking a look at this Marvel adaptation. You will get a whole new appreciation of the film. It's so good that it honestly feels like I'm experiencing the story for the first time. I'm assuming you've seen the film, but if not, BEWARE THE SPOILERS...





    [​IMG]



    If there is any character that didn't get a fair amount of screen time in Rogue One, it has to be Lyra Erso. If you read the prelude novel, Catalyst by James Luceno, Lyra is a central figure in Galen's evolving morality, and she is the rock of the Erso family. Yes, her death in the opening minutes of the film was necessary, but I don't think anyone who didn't read Catalyst (it's fantastic, by the way) can grasp how devastating a blow it must have been to Galen and Jyn. Yes, I know losing a mother and wife is heavy enough, but Lyra Erso was very special. Brilliant in her own right, she realized what the Empire actually was from the beginning, and was responsible for saving her family from Krennic. We get a quick glimpse of her here in the opening pages of this issue, and her expression tells you everything you need to know about her opinion of Krennic. Throughout the friendship and partnership Galen thought he had with Krennic, Lyra saw right through it. I think everyone pretty much knew Lyra was doomed once Krennic caught up to them, but if you read Catalyst, it was certain Lyra was going to be put down with Krennic giving the order. The Erso family lived on Coruscant for some time, and this frame is Krennic recalling the days where even he might have believed he had a true friend in Galen. For a moment, Krennic seems he may have remorse, but we all know better than that.


    [​IMG]



    There's a lot of emotion in this issue. The attack on the Eadu Imperial facility is felt by both sides of the conflict. This was one of my favorite frames in the issue. It's such a perfect visual metaphor for Jyn's lifelong struggle: on the run from the fire behind her, heading to the only thing in front of her that might be good and right. This time it's her dying father. I may have said this before, but Emilio Laiso's art in these issues is well worth the cover price.



    [​IMG]



    Jyn confronting Cassian was one of my favorite moments in Rogue One. This was a scene I looked forward to, and the team of writer Jody Houser and artist Emilio Laiso did not disappoint. Again, I really felt like I was experiencing this story for the first time. This adaptation not only does justice to the story, it enhances every moment.



    [​IMG]



    Well, hello there, Mustafar. Yes, you are reading that right. I know it's been confirmed that Vader's castle is on Mustafar, so this just underscores it for me. On a side note, I don't think it's a stretch to say we will be seeing this castle in either The Last Jedi or Episode IX. I've got a hunch that instead of Marvel Studios post-credit sequences, Star Wars films may give hints to what may appear in successive films by dropping locations or new aliens. Just an idea, but it would be a shame if this is to be the only glimpse we get of Vader's castle.



    [​IMG]



    Well, the Vader scene in this adaptation is pretty flat. We don't get a look at that Bacta tank. Hell, we don't even see it, other than the cover. In the comic, it's essentially the same scene, sans the Bacta dressing, and this odd frame of Vader watching Krennic's shuttle depart. I was a little bit let down, as I was really looking forward to that Bacta dressing in comic form. Oh well. Hopefully they'll make up for it when Vader goes full Jason Vorhees with a lightsaber.



    [​IMG]



    Here's a big scene that did not end up in the film. Mon Mothma has a pretty substantial conversation with Jyn. You can tell the leader of the Rebel Alliance sees a kindred spirit in Jyn. I almost got the sense Mon Mothma was a little envious of the freedom Jyn had to do what she felt she needed to, while Mon Mothma still had to maintain an aristocratic air. I'd love a good story about Mon Mothma's early days in the Rebellion. Despite being a senator, I'm guessing she's pretty good with a blaster or an X-Wing, especially if either are pointed in the direction of the Empire.



    [​IMG]



    When the Rebel officers break away with Jyn to head over to Scarif, Cassian explains this is not only a reckoning, but a redemption. We get a few quick glimpses of the awful memories these officers have. They know they are fighting a good fight, but taking lives still haunts them, and the Scarif attack is a chance they have to make a substantial difference in the galaxy. The heroes of the Rebel Alliance probably don't believe they are heroes. It preaches to the universal truth that war is brutal and slow, where the glory is either to die fighting for what you believe, or survive and honor those that did not. This is their chance to find honor on either in either of those fates.



    [​IMG]



    And they're off!!!



    Very pleased with how this series is turning out. Sure, it's not perfect, but I'm happy to be reading a story I already love from a different perspective. I'm hoping they give the eventual The Last Jedi adaptation the same treatment, as I was pretty disappointed with The Force Awakens one. I wouldn't blame you for holding out until all these issues are released in a volume, but whatever you do, make sure you get your hands on this. You'll be very pleased!



    [​IMG]



    Click HERE to check out and comment on this topic on our main site
     
    #1 SWNN Probe, Jul 7, 2017
    Last edited: Jul 13, 2017
    • Like Like x 5
  2. PrincessLeiaCB3

    PrincessLeiaCB3 Jedi General
    1030th Commander (Mod)

    Joined:
    Dec 3, 2015
    Posts:
    3,073
    Likes Received:
    22,794
    Trophy Points:
    148,417
    Credits:
    26,768
    Ratings:
    +25,946 / 23 / -12
    Great review @Kyle !

    I love so far this adaptation. I agree with you that it enhances greatly what we saw in the movie by incorporating elements from Catalyst and even The Clone Wars. It is worth getting all the issues!

    At the premiere, I started tearing up at this frame - due to personal reasons, having lost my father the same year - and I still think it is quite poignant. The comic makes a great service to it.

    Lol it is actually my theory for TLJ - listen to the next The Resistance Podcast to hear what are the other theories of our merry podcast bunch!

    (End of shameless plug LOL).

    Oh yeah I daresay we might find out more about Mustafar or any other prequel planets on the ST.

    I like how the whole package for Rogue One is full of really good material - movie/comics/books. Just like this comic adaptation I strongly recommend the novelization made by Alexander Freed. There's a epilogue written by Mon Mothma that is quite poignant and endearing. When I was reading this exchange between Jyn and Mon Mothma I couldn't help but think of that epilogue.

    And yes, I do want to read more about Mon Mothma, how did she get into the Rebellion, other than what ended up as deleted scenes of ROTS. I think she is a fascinating character and I would like to have like a book or some other kind of media telling us about her story.

    So true.

    And amidst all that, I couldn't help but love this frame:

    kaytoo jyn cassian rogue one comic.png

    #KaytooFTW #rebelcaptainforever :D
     
    • Like Like x 7
  3. Kyle

    Kyle Cantina Comic Guy
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Sep 6, 2014
    Posts:
    719
    Likes Received:
    1,855
    Trophy Points:
    6,314
    Credits:
    4,068
    Ratings:
    +2,647 / 24 / -22
    I’m very happy you liked it, @PrincessLeiaCB3!

    I would like to reiterate my request for more Mon Mothma stories! Please, give us a novel or Marvel series, or even a film, dedicated to the leader of the Rebellion. I think Star Wars fans would be thrilled to learn more about her. I’d be the first in line.

    This Marvel adaptation has certainly given us a more intimate look into the subtleties of the character’s vulnerabilities. It’s really like experiencing the story all over again for the first time. That thought right there proves they’re doing a lot of things right.
     
    • Like Like x 1
Loading...

Share This Page