SPECULATION Master Codebreaker Theory

That scene makes me wonder one thing.

How does Poe knows Maz Kanata ? She's Solo's friend not Poe's.

 

How does Poe and Holdo never met on D'Quarr ? There are 100 people on this resistance and a handful number of officers ?

Masterpiece ...

There are plot holes on every scene.

 

Your panning the scientific accuracy of a film that pretty much breaks every law of physics?

Great argument.

Funny how you had no issue with similar inaccuracies in the other films...

 

Eyy my Reylo titanic buddy is back!

I wanted to meet the master codebreaker. He seemed like a smooth interesting dude.

At least SW doesn't have Star Trek teleporters from new reboot. There'd be way more plot holes with them.

 

There is only one true MASTER code breaker

 

Hopefully we'll see him in episode 9.

 

This is an interesting possibility, McDiarmid.

This makes me think of something else:

At the end of TLJ,

Spoiler: TLJ SPOILER

Kylo is considered "Supreme Leader," but, wouldn't it be interesting if during Episode IX he learns the First Order does not follow his orders, partially or at all?

Instead, perhaps, they are secretly beholden to this potential mastermind "Codebreaker" character.

This surely would further fuel Kylo's rage and set the stage for all sorts of strange twists, perhaps even him forsaking the First Order to form his own new Vader-inspired Sith-like Empire (which, of course, would be doomed to fail).

 

Add to the list that during the Starkiller assoult the Resistance has not Bombers at all.
Because I think they should have used it, if they had some.
We're also told that the X-Wings coming back are what's left of the entire Resistance fleet.

Then TLJ opens.
Right where TFA ends, they say.

And: Bombers, A-wings etc..
The booster on Poe's x-wing.

Another one: who the hell told Rey about what happened in throne room in VI?
And when?
I've thought, that was something no one knew.

 

Tell me about using bombers without gravity ...

 

You didn't get what I said.

You can drop bombs in the vacuum, they won't drop anywhere, they will float around your ship.

 

This film takes place right after TFA. The Republic and Resistance is decimated. It's very likely Poe wouldn't know every officer.

It's fine that people don't like the story choices, but these "plot holes" are non existent.

Wait until you realize there's no sound in space. Does that ruin the entire series for you?

 

You mean he never been on D'Quarr or they have been rejoined by people across the galaxy ?

She's an admiral, he's a commander ... I highly doubt they are rookies who just come in the resistance and they never been in the same war room ...

Maybe I don't explain myself very well but this is very well understandable.

We're talking about masterpiece, perfection, the best movie of decade. Something brilliant.

 

I understand you well, but your complaint here isn't reasonable. Poe doesn't need to personally know every officer in the Resistance. She wasn't part of the leadership.

 

First he looks at her, when the MF lands and it's pretty obvious that she's Finn friend.
Then they're litteraly one next the other in the control room.
And it's not that she's dressed as you may expect from a resistance officer so that he may think she's one of them (putting aside
the previous scene).
Finally he's among those who chears when the MF leaves.

But I may undestand they passed on all of this to make us see the introducing scene.

But what you say, about TLJ opening just where TFA ends, doesn't feet well
with the idea that the Resistance at the beginning of the movie suddendly has
the bombers, the a-wings etc...

It's one or another.
Or there was enough time for everything (introduction - then just let it offscreen - and bombers, a-wings etc... coming)
Or there wasn't for none of them.

It's an unforgivable plot hole? No.
But cut the introducing scene or just make it different and it's more compelling.
Can we agree on that?

 

True but hey no sound in space either.

Honestly I figured the fuel was spent to keep ahead. Meaning when the pursuers adjust to intercept they are forced to maneuver. Maneuvering was the issue for fuel. But that might be me acting as apologist.