Should Disney erase PT from canon?

Semantics.

You knew my point yet diverted. I was speaking atypical, the norm.

Intellectual dishonesty.

Fine. I will equate your arguement as "Humans do not need oxygen to survive" when clearly they do.

Regardless I am terminating this conversation. Present your evidence every user is "trolling" in response to taking new positions of criticism and dislike of TFA, but you can't.

I cited evidence. Irrefutable. Observational. I have cited 3 examples amongst hundreds of thousands more evidence.

There is no need to further this conversation.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 17, 2017, Original Post Date: Jan 17, 2017 ---

Intellectual dishonesty. No further conversation is required.

Cited 3 examples out of hundreds of thousands. Positions and opinions changing. Thats evidence.

Intellectual dishonesty. Nothing further to discuss.

 

If that gets you out of my mentions, so be it.

 

I'm questioning how probative or useful your evidence is.

And nowhere did I claim that every user that posts criticism of TFA is trolling, that, is intellectually and factually dishonest of you to make that claim.

 

And once again, this is just your opinion and I respect it but you finding the PT bad in no way justifies that TFA was any good. That's like you trying to tell me that I shouldn't eat swamp muck because garbage tastes better. You think the PT was filled of bad things? Great! That's awesome and I am in no position to tell you what to like and what not to but you have to offer me the same level of respect cause your points are just as valid as mine as they are both just our personal opinions. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder my friend and one mans garbage is another mans treasure yet we all have to respect what the other thinks.

For me, Frederic Leighton was an awesome painter and this is a masterpiece:


While on the other hand I think that Pablo Picasso sucked as a painter and many of his works looked like something awful that a little kid with hardly any talent could do:






Yet to some people they would gladly pay thousands of dollars for Picasso's art and not waste a penny on Frederic Leighton's. This is just a matter of opinions and while I think Picasso's art sucks, I can't expect every single person to agree with me or say they are wrong just because they think Picasso was brilliant.

 

No need to further engage these two in conversation. Any logical mind who follows the conversations between me and these two users will see that my position is valid.

I refuse to label hundreds of thousands of new opinions, comments, as unreliable. I refuse to label them as "trolling". It is simply, scientific observational evidence and anyone of right mind, you, see's the same.

This is a factual statement: TFA faces growing criticism and prior mental positions have changed, all based upon hundreds of thousands observational evidence the form of reviews, comments, and the like.

Thank you for reading and I hope that this does not influence your personal opinion, rather makes aware of a growing dissent.

It was my pleasure to debate the truth and stay true to the scientific method.

Thank you and thank you for staying true to the truth, and not interjecting what you wish, as the result of the equation.

I also would like to say personally I enjoy TFA. Neither bad nor great, I still enjoy it. That is my personal opinion which I do not inject in any factual statements.

 

That's not what I meant and now you are just deviating from the points I made. You as well as many other posters who liked TFA and dislike the PT just have to accept that other SW fans are the other way around and love the PT but hate TFA but at least for me, I have had enough of this as I think things on this post are starting to get really heated. Not you by any means as you have been very respectful in your debating but some comments by others are starting to get just too personal for my liking so I will be moving along as Beast Man pooped on Skeletor's throne and I don't want to be around when he gets back after having his butt handed to him by He-Man again. .

 

That's cool. Both you and Amanaman are good peoples and it's been a fun discussion with you two.

Just be glad it wasn't Battle-Cat

 

100% agree. It's lame that all points made by others regarding how the PT was bad are super valid but when you bring the same thing up regarding what others think about TFA, it's all suddenly trolling and hating. It's one thing to like TFA as this is ok in my book but it's completely another thing to try to blindly deny that many SW fans just don't like it and more and more are getting off the hype train and starting to realize that the movie is just not that good.

 

Hey at least no one on this side has suggested Genocide....

 

I am under siege for negative ratings war by a specific user. However I just ignore it because when they can't hang mentally they resort to negative rating war syndrome. Childs play.

I am a Jedi like my Father before me....

 

You better not make me lower my guard and be hiding a Death Star in hyperspace! My home planet of Maridun is primitive and we can't handle firepower of that magnitude so you better be right on that no genocide thing!

 

As long as you agree to a de-escalation of arms on your side too!

 

De-escalation or arms??? Dude we only have sticks and rocks!!! Maybe a little poop flinging as well but nothing more!

 

Like reptilian Ewoks. I shudder at the thought.

 

This thread has got to go, its a stupid topic.

 

You seem as a cool person yourself RoyleRancor and I also enjoy debating with you.
PS: I have my eye on Battle Cat as well! Can't lower my guard!

 

I like the prequels just as much as I like the original movies so I say no.

 

It was delightful to see the results of this thread's poll: over 83% voted to keep the prequels. Yeah. The best sight I've seen all day.