SPECULATION Imagine if Luke were snoke

Luke is Dr. Jekyll and Snoke is Mr. Hide.
But nope, not happening.

 

Luke isn't Snoke. Plagueis is Snoke lol

 

Is Snoke a red herring for Darth Luke Skywalker son of Darth Vader is Luke Skywalker bad & good, the last few days people are saying Luke is the Villain in part 8. But is he? or is he so hurt that it will appear that he is the bad guy? Did he sense Han Solo his friend and sister husband was in danger and did not come to aid him? These are some of the questions people are asking to know where is Luke, where is his state of mind? Can Luke be so hurt that he turns away from his friends and family and the light side of the force? Can Luke be embracing the Dark Side of the Force? Can Star Wars have two main villains Snoke & Luke? Can there be two antagonists who are both against each other or both of them driven by the Darkside? Can Luke be so powerful that he see the wrong of the light side? Or can he see the good of the dark side so much it drives him to that edge?


Or can Luke be so hurt that he turns his back to the right side due to his hurt and pain and lost? Allow Han to die, see his sister Leia fighting the First Order and he turned his back on her and the Resistance? This is how Luke Skywalker can be bad in 8. That he is so hurt and him not aiding the Resistance makes him bad meaning he has the source to change things for the good but he turns his back to it, so he is bad in that sense. Not helping to turn a blind eye, or becoming blind justice.


Or can Luke be the main villain taking over the First Order? Or can Luke Skywalker assist the Resistance and take control of his self and end up destroying the First Order and using the Resistance for evil?

These are some of the questions people are asking about the Last Jedi where can Luke be in his mind, and what will be his main job in part 8 with his plot and twist. Can Luke be a Gray Jedi, even the term of Grey Jedi does not make sense, a Grey Jedi who not good or not bad, or a Jedi that use the Light and the Darkside but do not choose a side? If a person doesn't choose a side does it make him bad or good? I don't believe too much in the Grey Jedi theory because you saying a Jedi can be evil and good? There no balance with that, or one day with the Resistance and one day with the First Order, or one day turning your back to both of them?

Turning your back on both of them is for sure where we will see Luke in the Last Jedi, turning his back on the Resistance and a blind eye to the First Order so in reality turning his back to the First Order even knowing the evil they are spreading. So maybe this is the meaning of Grey Jedi not choosing a side and turning your back away from the Light side and Dark side.


Theory of OneForce OneBalance.

 

Luke is the Last Jedi. He cannot be Snoke and be the last Jedi. Jedi are light. For the Jedi to "end" Luke must abandon it or die without leaving a Jedi Padawan behind. If Luke take one step into shadow, the Jedi have ended.

 

Awesome addition to the discussion.

Was not even going to entertain the idea until you reminded me of this... now I can't stop thinking about how it would seriously work, even though I really dislike the idea of Luke being Snoke.

I must think about it some more before I draw any conclusions.


"Ride the Tide"

-SOAS

 

Not possible now.

 

They couldn't be more opposite.