RUMOR Will Ahsoka return in The Last Jedi? (Poll)

because she left the order. Technically she isn't a Jedi.

however in practice, in regards to the role she could fill if she was alive during the OT - she is basically a Jedi.

Its case where - technically the people using the defense "she isn't a Jedi so everything int he OT is fine" are right cause she isn't a Jedi, but also lets apply some logic and reason and honesty here - she is a Jedi in all BUT name, and could still fill the role of a Jedi in that story if she is around.

 

Right.

But my reason for posting was pointing out that her reason for leaving the Jedi wasn't because she wanted to hate people sometimes and shoot lightening like a Sith Lord as well as fight for the good guys. People seem to want her to be the Grey Jedi. But if anything the Jedi left their ideals that she strove to hold on to.

The same inconsistency that Anakin saw with Mace willing to kill the helpless Palpatine she saw during the CW but rather than push her to the darkside she pulled closer to the light.

 

as I said - a Jedi in all but name.

Technically people making that point are correct, but holding that argument is also dishonest because.....while she is not a Jedi she is not really any different then a Jedi.

 

She.... isn’t....a....Jedi..... om....

 

but she serves the same purpose in/to the story as a Jedi. You dragging your feet and refusing to accept it doesn't change it.

Let me put it this way - after TPM Maul wasn't a Sith, but did his role in the story change from what the role of a Sith would be? He was still evil, still used the darkside, still fought the Jedi/good guys etc.... Ahsoka is the lightside version of that.

 

She still isn’t a Jedi!!! Sure she might act like one but that doesn’t mean she’s a Jedi. She left the order! Therefore she is no longer a Jedi! Even Bendu said “Goodbye Ahsoka Tano, former Jedi Knight. I think even a point of time Cave Filoni says she isn’t a Jedi how many hints do u need???

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 26, 2017, Original Post Date: Sep 26, 2017 ---

Another good example Maul isn’t a sith even though he acts like one.

 

ok - what did I call her?

 

She would go into the category “Grey Jedi” I know it’s not canon anymore but the name fits her well or we could just call her a light side force welder idk but she can never be a Jedi again

 

Great - you agree with me. You can stop with the fake outrage

and "Grey Jedi" isn't a thing.

 

1 point: It’s not a outrage.

2 point: yes grey Jedi is a thing

 

No it's not

If I'm wrong, point me to the canon definition

 

Maul's role in the story didn't change after that?

I think that's pretty oversimplified. Sure, he was out for himself (much like a sith) but I think that his role changed significantly- note how he literally fights his old master at one point, becomes ruler of Mandalore, etc... his role as Palpatine's apprentice drastically changed. In fact, his acknowledgment of the importance of Luke shows how Maul is actively working and hoping for the fall of the Empire, an institution he may had otherwise supported if he'd remained loyal to Palpatine.

I think the same could be said for Ahsoka. Fact remains that we still don't know what happens to her between Twilight of the Apprentice and A New Hope.

Also, just to throw this out- Luke's importance doesn't stem from his stance as being a sword swinging warrior- it's not even because he personally is a Jedi. It's because he represents the future of the Jedi, something that Ahsoka could not represent. That's why she doesn't conflict with Luke's story.

 

Ahsoka is a gray Jedi and it’s not specifically canon YET but they are starting to make it canon read these articles

https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-history-of-the-gray-force-in-star-wars-1797311323

https://comicsverse.com/star-wars-the-path-of-the-grey-jedi/

https://thegameofnerds.com/2017/04/26/the-gray-jedi-dilemma/

And anyways if Ahsoka “isn’t” a gray Jedi then what should we call her hmm...

Maybe a really long name like a light side force wielder that isn’t a Jedi and isn’t a sith. Great name don’t u think? Or maybe we can just call her a Gray Jedi. Which sounds better? A super long name or a short one that fits where she is right now?

 

because he isn't a Sith. But he still a darkside using, out for himself lightsaber wilding bad guy who wants to kill Jedi.

Ahsoka could completel his training, train Leia and fight with luke. Her being there mean luke doesn't have to stand on his own.

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 26, 2017, Original Post Date: Sep 26, 2017 ---

in other words - its not a thing.

 

A Light Side Force user. She's not drawing from the Dark Side and that is in theory a part that makes a Force User a "Gray Jedi." There are Force Users that aren't the part of either the Sith or Jedi Order, like Snoke, Dathomirian Nightsisters or Ahsoka, but calling them "Gray Jedi" is simply confusing.

 

Did u read the posts? It’s becoming a thing. ( slaps face )

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 26, 2017 ---

How is it confusing?

 

then point me to the canon definition. Until then, its not a thing.

 

Bcause, for example, Snoke and Ahsoka don't share anything in common, except that they aren't Jedi or Sith.

 

The concept of Gray Jedi are (not yet) canon. Bendu represents the center of the Force. Ahsoka is a (highly) Force sensitive individual that also leans towards the center (which is why it was so cool to witness the two of them meeting). There have been other in-canon hints here and there about learning the balance between light and dark, the importance of balance, the importance of both, etc. However, there is no such thing in canon as being “gray.”

 

Not yet but isn’t better to call her a Gray Jedi instead of a very long name?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 26, 2017, Original Post Date: Sep 26, 2017 ---

Wait I thought Snoke was a sith? Then if Snoke isn’t a sith but he trained Kylo Ren so doesn’t that make Kylo not a sith also?