Should Lightsabers Be "Special"?

I never said they were replying. Can you read man? YYYYa man. Next thread.

 

Dude I'm so over it. Whatever. Neeeexxt.

 

The thing about me is when I'm wrong I'm wrong. And your right on this one. I thought you were just being a ********. My apologies. Am now commencing removal of troll rating. No Captain Nita chokes needed.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 2, 2015, Original Post Date: Oct 2, 2015 ---

My mistake. I've been in the cantina since the beginning. I will always be in discussion.

 

I'm confused. ??????

 

See now this is intriguing. I have to think about that one. I tend to forget that light sabers are one with the force.

 

Yea I agree it's a very intimate relationship between saber and creator.. That to me is good plot incentive. Those who view them as a presence in the force and not just a mere instrument as opposed to those who may wield them simply for military combat (first order training).

 

I'm in agreement. The two sides, the force spiritual/military first order lightsaber use needs to be fully distinguishable in order for the light saber to retain it's sacredness. The idea of a sacred weapon being synthetically manufactured needs to be viewed as trespass. I would advise people to expect some serious shockers regarding these issues in TFA. JJ has longed to make the star wars film of Mcquarrie's original concepts.

 

I remember Luke in one of the EU books telling a student of his to be careful because "those things can be tricky".

 

Yea so true. They need to have it where when the jedi look upon storm troopers wielding those things, they make fun of them and utter sarcastic remarks toward them in combat so as to degrade them for ever even considering such a thing.

 

I have my own views but it's funny to read everyone's views as well. We will see very soon which is the bright side of this speculation. I remember when it was me posting in the cantina and still having like a year plus to go. Don't put it past JJ to push the envelope. He's known for it when it comes to directing for already established franchises. (star trek)

 

That is to much emphasis on the lighsaber we shouldn't forget that he got that lighsaber from a random Jedi in the arena of AotC. I would be fine if its just a tool or a symbol that anyone can wear but truly shines in the hand of a force user. Conicaly we have seen everything: kids ith trainig lighsabers, a mercenary without force abilities using a darksaber, a cyborg that killed some Jedi and kept their lighsabers.looks like it didn't help those Jedi to have crafted their lighsabers, so why introduce this idea. George Lucas said it himself that it is just a symbol.