SPECULATION Is Luke Rey's Father? - The Evidence For and Against

When someone is surprised that others didn't get it, that means they thought it was............?

Have you not seen the movie?

And then say someone else (ie - not the people your waiting for) is out there and you will find family with him? I'd probably think thats my dad.

Maybe. Is it not possible there are reasons he wouldn't?

But you can't claim that the OT is about Vader when it only became about Vader 20 years after it was release. The OT is about Luke.

No you didn't - I showed you how with very minor tweeks (likely just dialog) all your original ideas still work.

 

We've alls een Daisy say what I'ms aying she did. When you're surprised someone didn't get something, you think that thing was............. ?

They go to see Maz to find the resistence and Leia. Han isn't avoiding taking Rey to Leia, he is TRYING to get find Leia.

Except no one said Rey's family is dead.

So if Maz knows Luke won't return to Jakku for reason X...............

Well if you want to be wrong about the OT, I guess I can't stop you.

Its exactly what I did. Other's even told you its what I did. If you need me to do it again, re-post all your story ideas (this time, leave the back story ones out).

 

Show me in the script and in video where Han says he is going to get them a"clean ship" for them. If he was going to get a clean ship for them, why did Finn take off? What does Maz say to convince him to go to Leia?

It means they aren't coming back.

How does Maz know her family isn't coming back?

Assuming the OT was written to be about Anakin and not Luke is whats silly.

There were, you even agreed when I deleted those ones. And your unwilling to post thema gain is very telling.

 

Rey Is Luke’s kid.

If you want to finish the Skywalker saga, then it’s pretty dour to just have the last Skywalker be an emo pos.

Poe and Finn are the non Skywalker characters. But Rey is. Given Rian Johnson and Colin Trevorrow’s approach, both of them have talked about respect the Prequels. Trevorrow said that he is going to tie in everything together in this 9 part saga.

If this is skywalker saga, then 789 are about the legacy of Vader, his grandchildren follow different paths. Rey and Ren.

It matters who Rey is. If you don’t know her backstory and just have some vague idea that she’s just some scavenger then it’s hard to care. If you wanted to establish as Rey as someone who isn’t a Skywalker, why cloud it all in a mystery box? What is the purpose of that?

 

LMAO!!!!!!!!

ANd what does Rey intend to do once they find this ship to get themto the resistance?

 

And her grandfather. Regardless of whether it's Luke or Leia.

To me I think it seems that Leia is sending Rey to Luke... because she's not her mother, she's her Aunt, and she believes Luke and Rey need each other. (I'm guessing.)

Luke teaching his daughter the ways of the force would be an amazing new twist to the Master/Padawan dynamic.

Could Rey just be another Jedi generated by the force like Anakin? Sure. There's that correlation with Rey's talents like young Anakin's. But I doubt it. She's like Anakin and Luke for a reason. To draw direct lines of their paths to hers. Her force dream when touching Anakin's lightsaber.

C'mon. Luke's reaction to her, the look in her eyes... for that to turn into "So, who are you?" Or some "I've felt you're presence for quite some time."

If they cleverly make her NOT a Skywalker, I'm ok with that... but to me, they've dropped SO MANY HINTS, that I don't know how they'd pull that switch.

 

its almost as if, if you knew she was lukes daughter itd seem obvious.......

 

You're right aout Han not going to see Leia, I forgot that.

But Rey then tells Finn he can't go they have to get BB8 back to the resistance. Seems od if Han doesn't want Rey to get to Leia is ridiculous. If that was the case, he'd take her back to Jakku BEFORE going to Maz's.

 

In that case I misunderstood when you said - Maz even tries to convince Han that he has to take them to Leia.
Ergo, Han wasn't planning on taking Rey to Leia - even though you say he knows she is her niece? Surely he'd think it important to tell her that?

So Han doesn't want to take her, because he doesn't think Leia wants to see him. But clearly he thinks its important enough for Rey to get to Leia instead of just taking her back to Jakku.

Now why would that be? Han MUST have some idea of who she is and/or what she can do if he is going to go these lengths and expense to get Rey and co. to Leia.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Jan 23, 2017 ---

You did try to charactize it like - So Han thinks that Rey might be Luke's daughter but at this point has little intention to take her to see Leia? Okaaaaay.

Even though he is trying to get the droid to Leia, and Rey is going with the Droid.

 

depends why Han realized it. If Rey looks identical to her mother, Leia will figure it out. Maybe the reason Han realized it was so obvious he knows Leia will. Maybe he'll tell Maz who will send word with them. Why is it so important for Han to tell Leia in person?

Maybe its a defeated father who never wanted to his daughter caught up in what he is.

 

If Ep VIII is about Luke Skywalker as the central character, is this enough for this saga to be about the Skywalker or do we need a dozen more ?

 

Sorry @Bandini and @master_shaitan, I have another take on it...

Episode VIII: The Last Jedi = No more PT era Jedi. Just sayin'...

 

The St, sure.

But is luke going to be the main character going forward to X, XI and beyond?

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Jan 23, 2017 ---

you mean the gambler didn't have tell and could hide his emotions? I'm shocked.

he wasn't willing to dump her anywhere or he would have. ANd he did take steps to make sure he got to Leia.